Today we’ll be doing a casserole with all the flavors you love in a supreme pizza. With ground beef, pepperoni, fire-roasted tomatoes, bell peppers and black olives, expect a very meaty pasta sauce. We’re going to combine it with a tube-type pasta like penne/ziti/rigatoni, put it in a casserole dish and bake it with a thick layer of mozzarella cheese on top to get those classic cheesy pizza strings everyone loves.
All the flavors you love from a pizza in a pasta casserole form big enough to feed a crowd. I’ve included the flavor profile of my popular red pasta sauce from the slow cooker beef and cheese pasta recipe, which is especially popular with the kids. The long and short of it is I always balance out the acidity of the tomatoes with some sugar so it has an even deeper flavor and make it more robust with some beef bouillon cubes and Worcestershire sauce. So expect more than tart tomato flavors from this casserole!
Let’s get started!
First we brown the ground beef in a dutch oven to melt away all the fat and get rid of it. How much fat you’ll get will depend on how lean it is. I’ve found though that even the leanest ones still tend to have some fat and we don’t want that. It’ll just make the pasta sauce oily and watery. While you’re browning the beef, start cooking your pasta until it’s just before al dente, about 1-2 minutes less than the package instructions. This is so the pasta doesn’t get too soggy while baking in the oven later. It will finish getting to al dente in the oven. I’ve found this method combats the typical stereotype of soggy pasta that pasta casseroles are famous for.
While the pasta is cooking, start slicing and dicing the pepperoni and the rest of the veggies. A good tip to dice up the pepperoni is to pile them into little stacks beforehand. Dice it stack by stack. You might be tempted to separate the diced pepperoni bits while dicing, but save it till all the dicing is done. The oil from the pepperoni will just make your grip on the knife slippery. Once it’s done, run your fingers through the diced pepperoni to separate them and set them and the rest of the diced veggies aside.
In the same pot you used to brown the ground beef, saute the onions and garlic over medium high heat until it starts smelling amazing. Honestly one of my favorite smells in the world. I can’t count the amount of times I’d have the hubs yell from the living room that whatever I’m cooking smells incredible and I’d yell back “It’s only onions and garlic!”. No kidding.
Back to the recipe, toss in the bell peppers and let it sweat a bit. Add in the beef, fire-roasted tomatoes and tomato sauce. This is when you reduce the heat to medium so it can come to a gentle boil. It’s also to save your kitchen from the huge mess that is spitting tomatoes. Honestly worse than camels. Or llamas. Toss in the diced pepperoni, olives and the seasonings with optional wine, if you like your pasta with that. Otherwise leave the wine out to keep it kid-friendly. Then we simmer. Not too long, just enough to let all the ingredients get to know each other on a first name basis.
Now you can stop here if you like prepping in advance and you can reheat this sauce the next day with freshly cooked pasta to bake. The flavors will marry even more sitting overnight. Or if you want to do it all in one day, combine the pasta with the sauce and put it all in a casserole dish.
Top with two cups of mozzarella cheese and bake for 30 minutes. It’ll get nice and bubbly in the oven and the cheese will brown slightly. If it isn’t brown enough for you, add in some broiling time. And you are done!
Serve, eat, enjoy with some Parmesan cheese and some freshly chopped parsley or basil.Print
♡ Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. You can learn more about it here.