We all love a good Alfredo pasta. Even though it’s insanely bad for you. Rich food in moderation I say. I mean my chicken alfredo pasta bake is pretty popular. So today I decided to make a stuffed pasta shell version of it. Yup, a shellfredo.
It’s oh so creamy with two types of cheeses, a rich Alfredo sauce which you can either get store bought or make your own and some Italian herbed chicken. Delicious. Decadent. Dreamy. But despite being all that, they’re sloppy and messy. Nope, it doesn’t look good. But I tell you this, trust me when I say it’s yummy and you should make it.
Here’s what it looks like coming out of the oven, Pretty good, huh?
Anyway, Alfredo sauce. You can buy it, if you know a good brand. I couldn’t find anything that wasn’t in a jar and it didn’t look all that great so I decided to make my own. I’ve included a simple recipe for it in the notes. One thing though, always always always use freshly grated Parmesan cheese. The bagged stuff just doesn’t melt well and you’ll end up with clumps. Something about preservatives interfering with the melty magic. I made that mistake a couple of times.
You won’t need a whole lot of pasta shells to fit a 9×13″ casserole dish. I had just enough filling to properly stuff about 20 shells. Any more and your shells will be underwhelming. Once you’ve cooked them till they’re al dente, rinse them off gently under cold water so they don’t stick together. I make a practice of separating them around this time because the shells have a stupid habit of spooning each other while cooking.
The sauteeing of garlic and chicken shouldn’t take too long. Add some Italian herbs and brown the chicken nice and good. Then it’s combining the ricotta mixture, adding in the cooked chicken and stuffing the shells. And onto baking!
At this point you can make a choice. Pour the sauce on the bottom of the casserole dish and line up your shells then bake it that way…or add some mozzarella to get a cheesy, crusty top. If you go the mozzarella route, broil it for 2-3 minutes or so at 450 degrees F or until you get molten lava cheese aka browned cheese. I decided to opt out of this step because I wanted the shells to still be visible enough for a shot so you can see what’s underneath.
And that’s about it! Enjoy your shellfredo (yes, I love saying that)!
♡ Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. You can learn more about it here.