Air Fryer Mexican Stuffed Peppers

These delicious air fryer Mexican stuffed peppers are filled with a hearty mix of rice, cheese, taco-seasoned beef and topped with more melted cheese. Take the classic family favorite meal and make it with the convenience of the air fryer in less than 25 minutes.

The air fryer takes another win with these air fryer Mexican stuffed peppers. With only 13 minutes total of air frying time, this recipe takes the usual time of baking stuffed bell peppers in the oven and cuts it in half for a fun, quick and easy weeknight meal. Stuffed with a delicious, savory combo of onions, garlic, rice, ground beef and Colby Jack cheese then topped with melted cheese and air-fried till crisp-tender, these peppers are a complete meal in themselves.

Customize them by adding in more fillings like corn, black beans, Rotel or diced tomatoes, green chilies, jalapenos and bacon bits or chorizo. You can also change up the cheese too with a Mexican or cheddar blend. Finish it all off with some melted cheese on top and serve as is or with sides like refried beans, or chips with some pico de Gallo.

If you have some leftover bell peppers, try making some sheet pan chicken fajitas or sheet pan sausage and veggies. In the meantime, let’s start air frying some peppers.

What Kind Of Bell Peppers?

There are subtle differences in taste between the colors of bell peppers. Green peppers, which are considered not yet ripe, are slightly bitter and peppery. Yellow, orange and red bell peppers are fully ripened and taste sweet and fruity with red being the sweetest and juiciest. Pick a color that suits your tastes.

While green bell peppers are the most commonly used ones, I find they taste a little bland compared to the brighter colors. In a dish like this where the pepper is the star of the show, you may prefer the red, orange, or yellow peppers as they’re bursting with sweeter flavors than the less ripe green peppers.

AIR FRYER MEXICAN STUFFED PEPPERS RECIPE TIPS

Bell peppers – You can chop off the tops like I did or cut the pepper in half and stuff it that way. Both ways will work and baking times should be the same. If you don’t mind a pepper overload, dice up the cut-off tops and saute them with the onions to combine with the stuffing.

Stuffing – Not all bell peppers are created equal so you may have some leftover stuffing. If you have any extra bell peppers, fill them with the leftover stuffing, or just dig in and enjoy! You could also saute the stuffing with the diced, chopped-off tops of the bell peppers.

When stuffing the cheese into the peppers, I layered it like a lasagna, starting with cheese at the base of the peppers, topping it with the rice and beef mixture, adding more cheese after and finishing with more rice and beef. You could also simplify this by adding the cheese directly to the skillet towards the end of cooking and mixing it all there.

Beef – I used lean ground beef so there was little to no grease to drain off the pan. If you’re using ground beef with more fat, make sure to drain the grease. I like using a meat smasher to break up any clumps in the meat.

Rice – You’ll need 2 cups of cooked rice which is roughly 1 cup of uncooked rice. You can cook your rice with a rice cooker, over the stovetop, or in the microwave using minute rice. The rice measurements are based on US cups and not standard rice cups.

Tomato paste – Tomato paste in a tube is a handy way of keeping it readily available for recipes. I use the Cento brand for tomato paste in a tube. We’ll be sauteing the tomato paste with the onions so that it caramelizes a little to give the ground beef a more robust flavor. You can skip tomato paste if you don’t have any on hand or just don’t like the taste – it won’t break the recipe. It’s just there to add a little bit more flavor.

Cheese – I used Colby Jack cheese but feel free to substitute with other cheeses like mozzarella, a Mexican cheese blend, or a cheddar blend.

Variations – Some versions of baked peppers use a stuffing of diced tomatoes or marinara sauce with Italian seasoning and top it with mozzarella. If you prefer an Italian-style stuffed bell pepper go with that, I just decided to go with Tex-Mex or Mexican flavors.

Make it in the oven – Bake in an oven-safe baking dish at 350°F for 30 minutes. If you want your peppers softer, add 1/4 cup of water to the baking dish, cover with foil and bake for 30 minutes. Remove foil and bake an additional 10 minutes until the cheese has melted.

Leftovers – Leftovers can be stored in the fridge for 3-4 days.

Reheating – I reheat these for 2 minutes in the microwave to get a more even heating on the stuffing before finishing it off in the air fryer at 360°F for 2-3 minutes.

NOTE: You may have to use additional bell peppers and air fry them in batches if you add more stuffing. You could also reduce the amount of rice and ground beef used in the original recipe. I used a Cosori 5.8 Qt. air fryer and managed to fit 4 peppers in there comfortably.

And that’s about it! Enjoy your stuffed peppers and let me know how you liked them and what substitutions you made in the comments below. Happy eating 🙂

MORE BELL PEPPER RECIPES TO TRY

• Sheet Pan Chicken Fajitas
• Healthy Sheet Pan Sausage and Veggies
• Cheesy Sausage Hash Brown Breakfast Casserole
• Healthy Egg White Muffin Breakfast Cups
• Homemade Spaghetti Sauce
• Big Steak Omelette

Print